ࡱ> kmj` RVbjbj2p&T\&:-~F(nnnn,,,,,,,$.h 1V,9,nn[, , , ,nn, ,, , , ,n: st& ,9,\ -0:- ,v1q+v1 ,v1 ,0Z@ ,W4,,+ :-&&&d&&&&&& ,gyudQkNewQSOBl ,{Nag :NNfۏNekĉ,gyuf[t^eTkNevdQ 9hnc Tg'Yf[YeRYv gsQĉ[ ~Tlf[bf[uxvzvwQSO`Q 6R[,gBl0 ,{Nag ,gBl@by,gyue Sb,gyu(WYef[Ǐ z-N\O:NYef[sNRvf[t^eTkNe0 ,{ Nag ,gBl;N[ev Tb__ۏLĉ [NevQ[Te_ 1uc[Ye^bc[Ye^~vcw_[0 ,{Vag ,gyuev SNNlf[b^v V-NۏL b _NSN9hnc]vf[/gtQSL b0 (W e c!PTR1\wQSOvtT[ۏL:N~vRg0d^ ghT[vMRgQY N[ ShQ@\'`vt0 ,{Nag ,gyueO(uf[!h~NpS6Rv\b eQ[_{SbvU_0cke0Se.sTeXdV*NR0 ,{mQag eXdSOste{ez@bʑ0Rgv QpQezv‰p0Vdk Xd-N NQs ,ge:N& &  b \O:N& &  KN{|vS$\vQ NQs e[& & ۏLNRgk v^_QN]v~ ُy!j|v0 NSOseQ[T‰pv(u0 ,{Nag evU_SOsckevteSO~g Tec:y gsQRvwQSOux0(WvU_-N ^ TeRQSe.sTeXdvux0 ,{kQag ecke^S_Sb_b[ 0;NSOfT0~b~ N*NR0T*NRKNޏ~cpS N͑ewu0 _b[ cQ v̀ofTvaIN (W_e _NSN[te{ev~gۏLN_0 ;NSOfT/fevsQ.0[@bvۏLU\_ʑTRg ^laDe[0;%N[0AmEu0{~fnx0\O:Nev8h_ ;NSOfT^S_ cgqev~gRb N TvR TRKN^S_ gQ(Wv;T|0 ~b~ /f[;NSOfTv;`~0(WُNR ^S_[ev;`SO`ۏLR_~ \ezcQv͑v0wQ gRe'`v‰pۏL͑0_veP _NSNۏL{USvU\g0 ,{]Nag eckeR^S_ glʑ0lʑN_Ǒ(ulvb__ kuUSrpe Y`$0a$0& & 0lʑxnNhp&{SKNT0 ۏLlʑv;N gN NQy`Q N vc_(uNNv0 O & & ckYW TVE~Nmlf[pgKQ @bcQv NNvi}T NSvQNvsQvagN:NNLuR Ng'Yvy)R FO_N&^egN_YΘi kY~NmqS:gvŏ荃XNS[;NCgleV[Rvcb0 `$& &  `$John H. Jackson,  The Changing Fundamentals of International Law and Ten Years of the WTO, Journal of International Economic Law 8 (2005): 3-15. N c_(uNNv‰p0 O & & }6q>yOQY~vt_(W-NN~nx[X[(W FO/f[E N@bvQY~YJSS/fNyb__ v^l gb:Nwckv?el|^y0(Wa'Y)R X[(W@w'YϑvfT NN}Y'YUR0bYm80[NlQrkf0*j_f[e0`$& &  `$ S[^tX]ŖT^^KQTyr 0a'Y)Rez YtQegveS 0 UOeы FURpSfN1979t^Hr ,{13 32u0  N [N(We-N N[Nʑv/gۏLʑ0 O & & ُ1\O[^:W1YupT?e^1Yupv `$ ُy1Yup[Nte*N>yOy^/f1u N)Rq_T0& &  `$ ^:W1Yup/fc(W N\:WT N^:W:g6RO[Dn NS_Mn sS[eHesvNyrQ0bcKN ^:W1Yup/f1uv^:WGWày^/}XbgOvNy`Q0_‰~Nmf[f (WN|Rt`SvagN N 1uzNv^:W~NmS[DnMn0R^/}XbgOr`0FOt`SvGP[agNv^ N&{Ts[`Q (WN NُN`Q N ^:WO1Yup N[hQzN lQqQirT YHe^ Oo` N[hQI{0?e^1YupR8^cv/f?e^(WcOyNirT NvL1Yup kY?e^RON NNl gHes ؏__[CgR [y bP%0 V [N(Wcke-N N[U\_vtۏL^8O0 O & & blNMRNv‰p NNS[ml]vrz`~ NS[[MRN,gv‰p_N N{_t `$@bN c!PtW@xv^ N/flSN _{ g@bR 0& &  `$ kY [N?elTf[[ReYeyrRevtċNmSُ7hN*NybsNyf[NSNy‰p^^z(W[ُyOHhpvEQRNKN N0FO/f``[|_dk N T N*N``[ꁫv``_NOSuSS bN\ُN``[c0RNw (uNNagagFhFh;`~R_~ /f&T g:_\O㉺NKNZeyrReǏS}^_ N:NN㉆NSN b NNb_ُyʑvaIN _N`uُyʑvw[S`'`0S_6q PeyrReُ7hgzvOP[ NY FO/fNUOʑ-NMQ0,ge-NvR_~N;`~Ǒ~ v^=\RcdOPFON Nbehi~[[‰ SO'Yeuvw[S`0 N [N(Wcke-N N[cv‰pۏL_3u0 O & & 6qr`/fNy[y:NNN1us^I{vSMRN{|r`0}6q``[N[NُySRr`vwQSO`Ql gNv wl `$FOُN>mf[[N(WSRr` N1\/f1uTs^I{v0a$& &  `$ kY ^e:N6qr` NvNNNvN:Y (Wُy~[s^I{vW@x Nb_bN NRNS[NRNvbN vr`mKQR:NNNgRu;m(WNy[Ye:v1uTs^I{r`KN-NbSh:N(W6qr` N k*NNN gOgq]vRTa_SZP,gU1r\OTYZPvN`v1uW\e:N6qr`KN NNN(W ewKNU^ ̀TۏLt`v Tt'` b GYKQ:N6qr`/fNy ^V[XQ NNꁫvS_~_gv^uNvQ ^S_v7h SǑSL:N1uNk*NN N^8^Qnx0WbcNN^S_v7h V __ cgqNy gNOP^vg'YS LN0Robert Nozick, Anarchy, State and Utopia, Basic Books Inc., New York, 1974, pp. 10-12.[v6qr`tSSNON 0GYKQNCgtDdIN  |QSS_NV$NyckIN!j_ 0 0f[N 0,{3 _lςezQHr>y 1992t^ ,{511 536u0 a$ T7hSN\O:NPOv؏ gwpQTf[[e[(WvQ 0^yf[?el 0@bvNNueg1u0SNObbuX[T;mRv6qr` [w]e[ 0^yf[?el 0 )n!Xы FURpSfN 1963t^ ,{222 223u0_VegeN6~``[Oyrg_N:N>yOvSYr`/fk*NN(WvQ-N1uTrzv0[_]Z^Oyrg(Wilhelm Weitling) 0TN1uvO(Garantien der Harmonie und Freiheit) 0 Y[Rfы FURpSfN 1960t^ ,{60 62u0lVTf[[O\l_N:N6qr` Nvu;m/fNN1u0NNs^I{v0S 0ASkQN~vlVTf[ 0 FURpSfN1963t^ ,{88 99u0 mQ [NvsQve.sۏLN~0 O & & u`&Otf[[y 'Y0WS)Y0WKNNir SbRir0 iir0_uir0eu}TSO v gNy NOVNNꁫ X[(W0 NNNvƋ:NW@xv Q(WNyOyf[QHr>y 2000t^ ,{3 35u[] \YeW\e 0Tf[pTRΑ 0 R30Ss^ы TgNlQHr>y 2000t^ ,{38uNT[]4be>Ne 0sX&Otf[sXTf[[ 0 g[f0hg1rlы SN'Yf[QHr>y 2002t^ ,{145uNT[]ȒL. ypQi` 0RirCg)R[ 0 R[N0R3ы -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y 2005t^ ,{161uNT0 N [NvsQvl_eN0zl^eNvc_ FONPN1 ^,geN蕢cvl_eN2 (W,gVv gsQe \O:NSvYVvl_eN0 \O:Nec;Nvl_eNT,gVvl_eNN, Nlʑ0 O 9hnc 0[lag~ 0vĉ[ nf z^@bBl0RvtNOv yr[Ype v^^ASR%Nm^Sb N\N4*NbXTV &TRsSƉ:N]0Ryr[Ype0`$ `$ 06R['k2m[lag~ 0,{I-25ag UO_O0Y[tы 0'kvzl,{16Hr 0 SN'Yf[QHr>y2006t^Hr ,{23u0 kQ VYbVE$ROVQ]lQ_QHrvHhO0 O & & (W'k2mNCglb NCgKQQvagNT gHe'`~1uN|RHhOnx[ Neg0`$& & `$ E. g., Brogan and others v. United Kingdom, Judgment of 29 November 1988, Series A, No. 145-B; (1989) 11 EHRR 117; Brannigan and McBride v. United Kingdom, Judgment of 26 May 1993, Series A, No. 258-B; (1994) 17 EHRR 539. lʑ-Nc_e.svyt^Hr0 O _e>f 0NASN~eTf[``xvz 0 l_QHr>y1996t^Hr0 _kSN;N 0FUlW,gxvz 0 l_QHr>y2002t^Hr0 _e;N 0NCgNVERl 0 l_QHr>y2004t^Hr0 2-NeыW0[VM|]\OYg/fvW\O _{hf  0fN T 0 ы QHr>yt^Hr0Y O []^_ 0ltf[ 0,{NwS ckegы -NV?el'Yf[QHr>y2004t^Hr0 [] ?pQS. WhY 0[?evTf[KN~ 0 ѐb0Rgы u;mfNew NTfN^2001t^Hr0 3-Neez0 1 Bg_-NQsvez\O 0ez T 0 }N 0Bg_ T 0t^,{g0Y O Ngm 0-NeRNݏlL:N{|WNvQNݏl{|WsQ|KNkxvz 0 }N 0stl_ċ 02003t^,{5g0 2 b~-Nvez\O 0ez T 0 }N 0b~ T 0t^ge,{Hr0 O -N5 0^?ef[ R 0 }N 0l6Reb 01994t^8g25e,{7Hr0 3 eƖ-NQsvez\O 0ez T 0 }N;N 0eƖ T 0 QHr>yt^Hr0Y O hgaf 0l_omSvQeEQel 0 }Nhgaf;N 0lFUlN 0,{1wS l_QHr>y1994t^Hr0 4-Nыe[VM|]\O 0ez T 0 ы }N;NN(Wehl;Nv`Q 0Bg_ T/eƖ T/b~ T 0t^,{g0 O [e]WSZSe 0L?eɋ-NT㉄vlt N 0 hg^zы }N 0stl_ċ 02001 t^Qc[S0 5eNGl/\OdkyN(W_ehl  0fN T 0 QHr>yt^Hr0 O [Y~Nm8fT\O 0-NVReQNLu8f~~l_eN-Ne[gq 0 l_QHr>y2001t^Hr0 6NNfN/\OdkyN(W_ehl  0fN T 0 QHr>yt^Hr0 O 0-NV'Y~vyhQfNlf[ 0 -NV'Y~vyhQfNQHr>y1984t^Hr0 []4b~M. lKQ 0[r%ml_'YxQ 0 NgSCQI{ы l_QHr>y2003t^Hr0 7-NeQ NDe\O 0ez T 0 Q@W eg0 O sedW 0z6eYZv z^O 0  HYPERLINK "http://www.cftl.cn/show.asp?c_id=534&a_id=2402" http://www.cftl.cn/show.asp?c_id=534&a_id=2402 2006t^4g25e0 8YeW\O uNVv8^ZPl N TBlT_ N>NOf  O Edgar Bodenheimer, Jurisprudence: The Philosophy and Method of the law, Harvard University Press, 1981. Gavin Anderson, Legal Pluralism and the Politics of Constitutional Definition, EUI Working Papers 2005/20,  HYPERLINK "http://www.iue.it/RSCAS/WP-Texts/05_20.pdf" http://www.iue.it/RSCAS/WP-Texts/05_20.pdf, visited on 2006-04-26. D. Colard et J.F. Guilhaudis, Le droit de la scurit internationale, Paris, Masson, 1987. Karl R. Popper, Logik der Forschung, (6. Aufl.), Tbingen, 1976 Wichard Woyke, Handwrterbuch internationale Politik, (7., aktualisierte Aufl.), Opladen, 1998. 7S[s^0}0sNP#uleQ;,{2Hr=0 l_eS>y1999 0 @K;>2 .. @02>B2>@G5A:0O 45OB5;L=>ABL <564C=0@>4=KE >@30=870F89. ., 1988. !. 24. 9Yee uNVv8^ZPl N TBlT_ N>NOf  O Louis Henkin,  The use of Force: Law & US Policy , in Louis Henkin, et al. Might v. Right: International Law and the Use of Force, Council on Foreign Relations Press, 1991. Yoram Dinstein,  The Right to life, Physical intergrity , Louis Henkin (ed.), The International Bill of Human Rights, Columbia Univ. Press, 1981. John H. Jackson,  Perspectives on the Jurisprudence of International Trade. Costs and Benefits of Legal Procedures in the United States , in: Michigan Law Review 82(1984). P. Tavernier, La guerre du Golfe: les grandes puissances et les autres ... ou le triomphe de l'ambigut, ARES Dfense et Scurit, 1984-1985, pp. 529-560. Dewost, La rserve de dveloppement du droit communautaire vue de Bruxelles, in O.Jacot-Guillarmod (d.), L'avenir du libre-change en Europe: vers un Espace conomique europen?, (1990) 270, n 716 Heinz Hauser, Die WTO nach Cancn, in: Aussenwirtschaft, Bd. 58 (2003), Heft IV, S. 459-488. BWCQ9j 0V[Nlh0ag}ln0N/ Nd0n0NO0KbL0K00h0W0f0 0 0'Yf[lf[֊Ɩ051 ](2001)0 #A5=:> . ". !>>B=>H5=85 8 2708<>459AB285 <564C=0@>4=>3> 8 =0F8>=0;L=>3> ?@020 8 >AA89A:0O >=AB8BCF8O // >A:>2A:89 6C@=0; <564C=0@>4=>3> ?@020. 1995. ! 2. !. 21. ,{AS Nag evvU_0Se.s0eXd^S_SwNu hǑ(u\ NS[SOcpS0 ,{ASVag [,gBlvQ[t Nfnxe SNBlc[Ye^NNʑ0c[Ye^[,gBlvQ[_N N\OQnxRT{e SBl;N{,gyuYef[voRb0Yef[yfN~Nʑ0 ,{ASNag (WS_e 9hnc gsQYe^b{tNXTv^ ,gBlSN~;N{,gyYef[voRb0,gyuYef[yfNTvQNvsQNXTFUۏLO0 ;;;,<.<0<:<<<<<0=4=:=B=J=P=>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>0?4??????????????????(*02:<@>@@@D@F@J@N@T@p@r@ҺҺۮҮҮҮh{]DCJaJh{]Dh{]DCJOJQJaJo(h{]DOJQJaJo(h{]DCJaJo(h{]DOJPJo(h{]DOJQJo( h{]DaJo( h{]DaJ h{]Do(D=>>r>x>>2?6?F????N@T@@@@g`g2g$d%d&d'd-DM NOPQWD`ggWD`g24$d%d&d'd-DM NOPQWD`4r@z@|@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@AhAjAlApAxAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA4B6B8B:B^B`BbBdBfBjBnBBBBBBBBC&C*CXC\CbCjCpCrCxCCCCCDDDD޻ h{]DaJ h{]DaJo(h{]DOJPJo(h{]Dh{]DOJQJo(h{]DOJQJaJo( h{]Do(h{]DCJaJh{]DCJaJo(J@AjAlAAA`BbBBBCCrCxCCD DgWD`gg`g24$d%d&d'd-DM NOPQWD`42g$d%d&d'd-DM NOPQWD`gDDD>D@DFDhDjDDDDDDBEDEbEdEhEpEEEEE(F*F>FFFFFG(GTGXGZGGȹШȜqhh{]D6CJaJh{]DB*CJaJo(phh{]D6B*CJaJo(phh{]D6B*CJaJphh{]DB*CJaJph!h{]D0J>*B*CJaJo(phjh{]DCJUaJh{]DCJaJjh{]DCJUaJh{]DCJaJo(h{]DOJPJo( h{]Do( h{]DaJo( h{]DaJ# D@DFDbEdEEEFVH IIWWW:4$d%d&d'd-DM NOPQWDXD2YD2`424$d%d&d'd-DM NOPQWD`42g$d%d&d'd-DM NOPQWD`ggWD`g GGG"H$HVHHH I I(IIIIHJJJLJTJVJlJtJvJJJ8K:K>Kø˪˄sdWWSNG h{]DaJo( h{]Do(h{]Dh{]DCJOJQJaJo(h{]DCJOJQJ^JaJo(!h{]DCJOJPJQJ^JaJo(h{]DCJOJQJaJh{]DB*CJaJo(phh{]DB*CJaJphh{]D6B*CJaJphh{]D6CJ]aJh{]DCJaJh{]DCJaJo(h{]D0J>*B*CJaJphjh{]DCJUaJj1h{]DCJUaJILJJ:KKIAgWD`g:g$d%d&d'd-DM NOPQWDXD2YD2`gA$D$d%d&d'd-D7$8$H$M NOPQWDXD2YD2`Da$:4$d%d&d'd-DM NOPQWDXD2YD2`4>KFKKKKK LLXLZLLLLLLMMXMpMrMMMNNNN,NO$OJO^O8PhPPPvQR.R0RHRR޼ޟޟʈ޼ޟޟz޼oʖoʖfh{]D6CJaJh{]D6CJ]aJh{]DB*CJ]aJphh{]DB*CJaJo(ph3h{]DCJaJo(h{]DB*CJaJo(phh{]D6B*CJaJo(phh{]D6B*CJaJphh{]DCJaJh{]DB*CJaJph3h{]DB*CJaJphh{]DOJPJo( h{]DaJo( h{]DaJ(KKLN`OP0RRa24$d%d&d'd-DM NOPQWD`4:4$d%d&d'd-DM NOPQWDXD2YD2`42g$d%d&d'd-DM NOPQWD`gRR,S.SVSXSZSTTTTTUUUUUUUVVȿȿȿh{]DCJaJo(h{]DOJQJaJo( h{]Do(h{]DOJQJo(h{]DOJPJo(h{]DCJaJh{]DCJKHOJQJaJo(h{]DCJKHOJQJaJh{]DCJaJo(RZSTTTTUUV{{{{{{gWD`g:4$d%d&d'd-DM NOPQWDXD2YD2`4A$D$d%d&d'd-D7$8$H$M NOPQWDXD2YD2`Da$0182P. A!"#$%S 1DyK /http://www.cftl.cn/show.asp?c_id=534&a_id=2402yK ^http://www.cftl.cn/show.asp?c_id=534&a_id=2402!DyK +http://www.iue.it/RSCAS/WP-Texts/05_20.pdfyK Vhttp://www.iue.it/RSCAS/WP-Texts/05_20.pdfJ@J cke $1$a$ CJKH_HaJmH nHsH tH$A@$ ؞k=W[SOFiF nfh*B*ph.. yblFhe,gCJaJpPQ#$VW  Iu/0i{-.FGJvx^_wx{68   " # & q s K L 2 o p 2mLYc$'N89jmFIyz ,q3]9`=>fg00y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0y0(0000000l;r@DG>KRV,.0246$"%=@ DIKRV-/1357V]XX8@ (  HB  C DHB  C DHB  C DHB   C DHB   C DHB   C DHB   C DHB   C DB S  ?v6q m #~~ththt ht ht ht ht ht֌}tz׌}D،}4ٌ}tpڌ}ی}ur r i}}z z v9*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsplace9*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsStateB*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagscountry-region  z QTU$'(UWZ[  HItu.034Y[hiz|z]`v3:6 = C    1 5 8 ? j k l m s |   y z {         < @ C F J &/#$&()*FOPRUjl&()23EFH(27<CKLZ 39?NO[\iju]bck 9?ELP]afgtux|$*: #$)>BCegkl OQ #$Wx  HItu.0hiz{,.EGIKux]_vxz|586   ! # % ' p s J L m p 12lmKLXYbc&'MN79lmEFHIxz    "23vwz]`>eg3333333#$GK Y]cj{L8<{]DMv$Njm@##|:##4```$`:UnknownGz Times New Roman5Symbol3& z Arial;[SOSimSun;ўSOSimHeiO  MS MinchoMS Gothic qh ʤFZF R4R4!-!),.:;?]}    & 6"0000 0 0 00000 =@\]^([{  0 0 00000;[2d 2qHX(?{2 Tg'Yf[lf[b,gyueBlHEZP_o(u7bOh+'0  , L X d p| ƷþþþþרҪHEZPNormal ΢û10Microsoft Office Word@40@D+~@dg@@kutR՜.+,D՜.+, X`lt| JLU4 l 8@ _PID_HLINKSA$ 4+http://www.iue.it/RSCAS/WP-Texts/05_20.pdf>  /http://www.cftl.cn/show.asp?c_id=534&a_id=2402>   !"#$%&'()*+,-./012345678:;<=>?@BCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXY[\]^_`acdefghilRoot Entry F.tnData 91TableAv1WordDocument2pSummaryInformation(ZDocumentSummaryInformation8bCompObjm  FMicrosoft Office Word ĵ MSWordDocWord.Document.89q